nextbest

See what everyone's saying

About

Last updated November 15, 2026

What is nextbest

nextbest is community-sourced skincare product rankings. We aggregate real discussions from Reddit beauty communities to show you what people actually use and recommend. We also grade the peer-reviewed studies on skincare active ingredients, starting with acne, so you can see what the research says alongside what people report. No influencers, no paid placements — just real people sharing what works for them.

Who runs nextbest

nextbest is built and edited by Kayleigh Migdol. I started it because I have acne-prone skin and was tired of piecing together product advice from dozens of Reddit threads. I decide what the site covers, set the rules every ranking and research grade follows, and approve every new product before it appears. If something here is wrong, it's on me, and I want to hear about it: kayleigh@nextbest.one.

How it works

We scan thousands of Reddit threads from beauty communities. AI reads through them and picks out product mentions, noting what people recommend and why. Separately, we search PubMed for peer-reviewed studies of active ingredients and grade how well the research supports each one for a concern — see how we grade research. On most concern pages, products are ranked by a community score — how often the community mentions them, weighted by how recent each mention is, how upvoted it was, and which subreddit it came from. The acne page blends that community score with research evidence on each product's active ingredients. Everywhere else — and on the handful of concerns with too few products to rank meaningfully — it's simple mention volume: more mentions means a higher ranking.

How AI and human review fit together

AI does the reading. It goes through thousands of Reddit threads, picks out which products people mention and what they say about them, and drafts the short summaries you see on product pages. A person decides what gets published:

  • Every new product is approved by hand. A new product doesn't appear until I've checked its name, brand and category against the brand's own listing.
  • Buy links are checked against the exact product. Retailer links are matched to the exact product and size, and wrong links are pulled.
  • The rules are written by a person, not a model. Rankings come from a fixed formula (described below), and research grades follow fixed rules about how many studies, and of what kind, a grade needs. AI doesn't pick winners.
  • Errors get fixed at the source. When I find a mismatch (a product credited with another product's mentions, a wrong ingredient, a bad summary), I correct the data and rerun the step that produced it, so the fix sticks.

What a person does not do is rewrite every product summary line by line. Those are AI-written from the linked Reddit threads, which is why every product page shows its sources: you can read exactly what people said.

How nextscore works

nextscore is a single 0–100 number for how well a product has been received. It is calculated from verdicts — mentions where someone came down clearly on one side, saying a product worked for them or that it didn't. nextscore is based on the share of a product's verdicts that are positive, adjusted for how much evidence sits behind it. Today those verdicts come from community discussion on Reddit. Peer-reviewed studies are graded separately and are not part of nextscore. nextscore is defined over verdicts, not over the source those verdicts come from.

Not every mention is a verdict. Mentions that are neutral or mixed — “it's fine, I guess”, “lovely texture, but it broke me out” — are counted as discussion, not as verdicts, and are excluded from the score. They tell you a product is being talked about; they don't tell you whether it worked. Scoring them somewhere in the middle would invent an opinion nobody expressed — a passing mention is not a review.

A product with few verdicts is pulled toward the catalog-wide average, and only earns a distinctive score once it has enough evidence behind it to pull away. That pull is worth 10 verdicts, which is why five positive verdicts out of five reads as well-liked but thinly evidenced, rather than as a perfect 100. The pull works the same way in the other direction: five negative verdicts out of five land in the mid-50s rather than near zero. A middling score usually means there isn't much evidence behind it yet — not that a product is mediocre — so read it alongside the verdict count. Below 5 verdicts we show no score at all — just “not enough verdicts yet”.

Every score is shown with the number of verdicts behind it, because the count is what tells you how much to trust the number. Scores update as new discussion is ingested; the pipeline runs daily, so a score moves as the conversation does. It is a read on reported experience, not a lab test or a verified-purchase review.

The communities we source are chosen for experience-based discussion — people reporting what a product actually did for them over weeks and months — not for volume. A bigger, more general forum would produce more mentions and fewer verdicts worth counting. More on where the discussion comes from.

How we grade research

Alongside community discussion, nextbest grades the peer-reviewed research on skincare active ingredients for specific concerns, starting with acne. This section explains where the studies come from, how each one is read, what each grade means, and how grades affect the acne ranking.

Where the studies come from

Our research source is PubMed, the index of biomedical literature run by the U.S. National Library of Medicine. We search it separately for each ingredient and concern, asking PubMed for meta-analyses, systematic reviews, randomized controlled trials and other clinical trials, and retrieve up to 40 matching records per search. A study found by an earlier search is kept even when a later search no longer returns it.

How each study is read

Each study's design comes from PubMed's own publication-type labels, not from AI. Most of the studies we collect are meta-analyses, systematic reviews, randomized controlled trials or other clinical trials; a study PubMed labels as another design, such as an observational study, keeps the label PubMed gave it.

An AI model reads each study's abstract and records whether it is relevant to the ingredient and concern, whether it measured the ingredient itself, which way the result went, and any certainty rating the paper gives its own evidence. Only studies that measured the ingredient itself count toward a grade; a review that lists the ingredient among many treatments without reporting on it does not.

What each grade means

We show a grade for an ingredient and concern only when there are at least 2 relevant studies, including at least 1 randomized controlled trial or a stronger design such as a meta-analysis or systematic review. Each grade means something specific:

Strong evidence

More than half of the studies that measured the ingredient found a benefit, across at least 10 such studies, including at least 1 positive meta-analysis or systematic review.

Exact rules for Strong evidence

Strong evidence means more than half of the studies that measured the ingredient itself found a benefit, there are at least 10 studies that measured the ingredient itself, and the ingredient has at least 1 positive meta-analysis or systematic review that measured it and whose authors do not rate their evidence low or very low. If any positive meta-analysis or systematic review that measured the ingredient itself rates its own evidence low or very low, the grade can be no higher than Some evidence.

Some evidence

More than half of the studies that measured the ingredient found a benefit, including at least 2 positive randomized controlled trials or stronger designs.

Exact rules for Some evidence

Some evidence means more than half of the studies that measured the ingredient itself found a benefit, and at least 2 positive randomized controlled trials or stronger designs are among them, without meeting the bar for Strong evidence.

Not proven yet

The research doesn't establish a benefit yet; this grade is not a warning that an ingredient is harmful.

Exact rules for Not proven yet

Not proven yet covers everything else, however many studies there are: half or fewer of the studies that measured the ingredient itself found a benefit, no study measured the ingredient itself, or too few positive trials or reviews measured it to reach Some evidence. Not proven yet means the research doesn't establish a benefit yet, not that an ingredient is harmful.

How it affects the acne ranking

Community score 75%Research evidence 25%

On the acne page, a product's ranking blends 75% community score with 25% research evidence. A product's evidence value is the best grade we show for any of its verified active ingredients, counting only actives named in the product's name, given a stated strength, or listed high in its ingredient list. A product with no graded active ingredient gets a neutral evidence value, the same as a “Not proven yet” grade, so a product is never marked down for research that is missing or thin. It can still be passed by a product whose actives have stronger evidence. Only Some evidence or Strong evidence raises a product's score above that neutral value.

Research grades are separate from nextscore: studies are not part of nextscore.

For an example, see the studies on Adapalene for acne.

Research context, not treatment advice. Studies are about the ingredient, not any one product.

Which communities we source

We read thousands of real Reddit beauty discussions, from communities where people report what a product actually did for them — not where it gets mentioned most.

Why trust this

Rankings are based on genuine community signal — a recency- and upvote-weighted community score on concern pages (blended with graded research evidence on the acne page), mention volume elsewhere — never on paid placements. We don't accept money from brands to boost rankings. Affiliate links, where present, don't influence which products appear or where they rank. The methodology is transparent: you can see which threads informed each product's ranking, so you can verify it yourself.

Questions or corrections? Email Kayleigh at kayleigh@nextbest.one.

We use cookies to improve your experience. Learn more