Rohto Mentholatum Mentholatum Melty Cream Lip Fragrance Free SPF25 PA+++ Dupes & Cheaper Alternatives
From 17 Reddit threads · Updated October 14, 2026
SPF 25 lip balm with petrolatum keeps dry lips moisturized without sunscreen taste. The catch: waxy thickness bothers people wanting a thinner balm. Here's what Redditors reach for instead.
The short answer
Best Overall AlternativeFive ceramides for barrier support · $6.40 · 11 ml
Best for Sun ProtectionGlossy occlusive layer that stays put overnight · $4.76 · 10.4 ml
#1
Best Overall Alternative
- Size: 11 ml
The why
A gel-textured lip essence layer with ceramides and occlusives for peeling, cracked lips, especially when overnight protection is needed. It suits people who hate thick balms, though the odd taste and occlusive feel lose fans.
One minus
Flavor is gross and lingers in the mouth
Good forDry Skin, Sensitive Skin
The original, at a glance
- Why people love it
- SPF 25 without bitter sunscreen taste
#2
Best for Sun Protection
- Size: 10.4 ml
The why
A castor-oil-rich lip balm that leaves a glossy occlusive layer for severely chapped, retinoid-dried lips. It works best over damp lips or moisturizer, though reactive users report burning, rashes, and breakouts around the mouth.
One minus
Burning, redness, and eczema flares hit reactive users
Good forDry Skin
Both recommended for Sun Protection.
Other alternatives worth a look
SPF26 PA++ for daytime lip sun protection · 3 recs
Petrolatum
Lanolin treatment, not merely an occlusive · 14 recs
Heavy/RichDry Lips
Browse more
By concern
Reddit's best lip care by skin type or ingredient list
Looking for a different product?