Prequel Scar Solutions Silicone Scar Stick Dupes & Cheaper Alternatives
From 13 Reddit threads · Updated November 19, 2026 · Edited by Kayleigh Migdol
60% silicone stick helps flatten and remodel scars; no SPF for lingering redness. The catch: doesn't address redness or hyperpigmentation alone; sunscreen still matters. Here's what Redditors reach for instead.
The short answer
Best Overall AlternativeGel format for tret-irritated skin; lighter than balm · $17.29 · 39.9 ml
Best for HyperpigmentationRedness-fading scar gel for fully healed skin
Best for Redness / IrritationReddit HG for acne, redness, and marks
#1
Best Overall Alternative

- Size: 39.9 ml
The why
A 21% glycerin gel with panthenol and dimethicone layers over retinoid-irritated patches without the balm’s heaviness. It fits oily or combination skin better than very dry skin, which may need more occlusion and can find this greasy or insufficient.
One minus
Can trigger breakouts or congestion, including fungal-acne complaints
Good forSensitive Skin
Both recommended for Redness / Irritation.
The original, at a glance
- Why people love it
- 60% silicone for scar flattening and remodeling
#2
Best for Hyperpigmentation

The why
A daily scar gel with 0.5% allantoin, onion extract, panthenol, and sodium hyaluronate for healed scars and lingering redness. It rewards religious application over months, yet inconsistent users and some hyperpigmentation cases see little or no change.
One minus
Not a quick fix; some users report no visible change after months
Both recommended for Hyperpigmentation.
“Honestly? Mederma scar gel/cream.”
— Reddit, r/SkincareAddiction
#3
Best for Redness / Irritation

The why
A 10% azelaic acid suspension targets acne, redness, and leftover marks. Research shows azelaic acid clears acne better than placebo, while Redditors report real improvement but complain about the thick, silicone-heavy texture, pilling, and occasional burning.
One minus
Pills under sunscreen, moisturizer, and makeup
Both recommended for Hyperpigmentation.
“Every night apply The Ordinary Azelaic Acid Suspension 10%”
— Reddit, r/SkincareAddiction
Other alternatives worth a look

2% salicylic acid targets clogged pores and blackheads · 386 recs
Dewy FinishLightweight
Studies support adapalene 0.1% for clearing acne · 803 recs
Gel TextureDewy Finish
10% azelaic acid; OTC HG status · 32 recs
LightweightRedness / Irritation
10% sulfur short-contact mask; cheap breakout workhorse · 182 recs
Fungal AcnePerioral Dermatitis
Browse more
Reddit's best treatments by concern
Looking for a different product?