Alternatives to I'm From — Reddit's Picks
From 336 Reddit mentions of 8 I'm From products
The short answer
Instead of Rice Toner
141 Reddit mentions of the original · original $5.60 · 30 ml
Watery-milky hydration that sinks in fast · The catch: Can sting sensitized or eczema-prone skin
Best Overall Alternative
Tirtir·Toner
Why: 11% less per ml ($0.17/ml vs $0.19/ml) · Discussed alongside the original in 26 Reddit threads
Instead of Mugwort Essence
123 Reddit mentions of the original · original $16.00 · 150 ml
Fast redness relief · The catch: Not enough hydration on its own
Best Overall Alternative
Black Rice Probiotic Barrier Essence
Haruharu Wonder·Essence
Why: A top-10 Reddit pick for Skin Barrier · Discussed alongside the original in 26 Reddit threads
Instead of Mugwort Mask
29 Reddit mentions of the original
Cooling relief for hot, sensitive skin · The catch: Bright-red breakouts reported after one use
Best Overall Alternative
DIVE-IN Low Molecule Hyaluronic Acid Mask
Torriden·Wash-Off Mask
Instead of Honey Mask
16 Reddit mentions of the original · original $22.00 · 70.1 ml
Instantly cushions dehydrated skin
Also recommended
innisfree·Wash-Off Mask
Why: 54% less per ml ($0.14/ml vs $0.31/ml) · Reddit's complaint about the original: “Rich, waxy base can feel heavy on acne-prone skin”
Other I'm From dupes
nextbest surfaces what Reddit actually recommends. “Where to buy” links are affiliate links — we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.