Ranked by Reddit mentions · Updated November 2026 · How we rank
749
Reddit threads
21 products
Reddit’s standouts are Banila Co Clean It Zero and Clinique Take The Day Off, praised for melting makeup and water-resistant sunscreen and rinsing clean.
A solid balm that melts to oil. First step at night, then your usual wash.
The why
A targeted, leave-on pore treatment uses a roughly 10–15-minute contact time before rinsing or gentle removal. It suits oily, congested noses, including tret users, but over-scraping or prolonged wear can inflame sensitive skin and disrupt the barrier.
One minus
Short-lived results; pores refill within days
Good forOily Skin, Sensitive Skin, Dry Skin
Not your texture?
Richer pick
Green Clean Makeup Removing Cleansing Balm
Farmacy56 mentions
Clean It Zero Cleansing Balm Original
Makeup-melting cleansing balm that emulsifies cleanly; fragrance and breakout complaints persist.
Banila Co151 mentions
Take The Day Off™ Cleansing Balm
Smooth emulsifying balm removes waterproof makeup and sunscreen; pricey, occasionally irritating.
Clinique97 mentions
Lightweight cleansing balm melts sunscreen and makeup cleanly; occasional breakouts.
Beauty of Joseon84 mentions
Oat Makeup Removing Cleansing Balm
5% oat oil balm removes SPF and makeup; leaves a stubborn oily film.
The Inkey List67 mentions
Green Clean Makeup Removing Cleansing Balm
Sunflower-oil balm dissolves waterproof makeup and sunscreen; irritation-prone skin may flare.
Farmacy56 mentions
Holy Hydration! Cleansing Balm
Affordable cleansing balm removes makeup and sunscreen; eye-friendly for many users.
e.l.f.52 mentions
Makeup-melting balm removes stubborn mascara without tugging; fragrance-heavy and occasionally breakout-triggering.
Heimish36 mentions
Pro-Collagen Original Cleansing Balm
Thick oil-like cleanse; breakouts and premium pricing divide the community.
Elemis27 mentions
Makeup-melting cleansing balm; stubborn residue and breakouts divide users.
CeraVe23 mentions
Makeup-melting cleansing balm that emulsifies creamy and rinses away without greasy residue.
Geek & Gorgeous21 mentions
Emulsifying cleansing balm melts makeup and waterproof mascara; pricey, packaging-heavy 50ml.
Dr. Althea17 mentions
Grapeseed-oil cleansing balm melts waterproof makeup without stinging; leaves skin moisturized.
BYOMA17 mentions
Banila’s creamy, non-stripping feel suits dry skin, but fragrance and breakouts divide users; Clinique is fragrance-free yet pricey, and some report residue. Beauty of Joseon offers a lighter, unscented option, though acne-prone users still report breakouts and compromised skin can react.
We use cookies to improve your experience. Learn more