nextbest

See what everyone's saying

Carrot Carotene Calming Water Pad

Sensitive SkinToner Pad

Carrot Carotene Calming Water Pad — Reddit Reviews

by Skinfood

88nextscore11 verdicts

Updated September 25, 2026

Hydrating carrot pads for lightweight pre-makeup prep; fragrance can sting.

What the community says

A lightweight toner pad format with carrot root extract, beta-glucan, glycerin, and sodium hyaluronate. People like it for quick hydration and smoothing skin before makeup, but the fragrance oils are a real deal-breaker for acne-prone or reactive skin.

From Reddit

Backed by 12 threads from r/AsianBeauty, r/koreanskincare and 1 more.

Read the threads ↓

What people love

  • Lightweight pre-makeup hydration
  • Easy swipe-on pad format
  • Nice for sensitive skin when it behaves

Watch out for

  • Too much fragrance for some noses and reactive skin
  • Not acne-safe for some users
  • Pads can be more hydration than treatment

Product details

Concerns

Product Traits

Key Ingredients

Skin type data limited

Where to buy

Real Reddit threads — 18 mentions across 12 threads

Skinfood Carrot Carotene Calming Water Pad on Reddit, in one place — 12 threads from r/AsianBeauty, r/koreanskincare and 1 more, summarized.

“The carotene / carrot masks were quite trendy like a year or two ago”

Mentioned

“Their carrot carrotene toner was popular a year or two ago.”

Mentioned

“Skinfood was pulled from some US retailers but they still have the same aesthetic and all.”

Mentioned

“I’ll 3rd the Mary & May collagen box and also include the Skinfood Carotene box.”

Mentioned

“vt, skinfood, mediheal etc…”

Mentioned

“they sell tubs of 30 sheet masks”

Mentioned

“Skinfood carrot carotene calming water pad”

Cautionary

“Too much fragrance and not acne safe.”

Cautionary

“The pad's size is big so I could also use it as a mask.”

Cautionary

“Skinfood Carrot toner pads”

Positive

“SKINFOOD Carotene toner pads are pretty popular for pre-makeup prep due to how lightweight the toner is.”

Positive

“I use the carrot carotene calming water pads every morning. They have been so good for my sensitive skin!”

Positive

“skinfood carrot toner pads”

Positive

“I have the skinfood carrot carotene daily masks and love those!”

Positive

“They are perfect if you are wanting light hydration”

Positive

“skinfood carrot toner pads”

Positive

“Carrot Pads”

Positive

“round lab birch juice sunscreen”

Positive

Dupes & Alternatives

Compare all 24 alternatives

Reddit's best toner pads by skin type

We use cookies to improve your experience. Learn more