Holy Hydration! Eye Cream — Reddit Reviews
by e.l.f.
Updated October 3, 2026
Basic moisturizing eye cream with peptides and hyaluronic acid; good under tret.
What the community says
A no-frills eye cream built around glycerin, peptides, sodium hyaluronate, and emollients. It’s the kind of thing people use at night under tret or on dry, itchy lids; very dry eyes may want something richer.
What this means for you
What people love
- Basic moisturizer, not a fancy actives cocktail
- Good under tret and on dry, itchy eyelids
- Peptides plus hyaluronic acid for under-eye hydration
Watch out for
- Won’t do much for stubborn dark circles
- Pretty plain — if you want retinal or acids, this isn’t it
- May be too lightweight for very dry under-eyes
Product details
Concerns
Skin Type
Skin type data limited
Where to buy
Real Reddit threads — 7 mentions across 6 threads
e.l.f. Holy Hydration! Eye Cream on Reddit, in one place — 6 threads from r/30PlusSkinCare, r/acne and 2 more, summarized.
“Eye cream: Elf Holy Hydration Eye Cream.”
Positive
“Sorry, I can’t edit the post, but this is the routine: Eye cream: Elf Holy Hydration Eye Cream.”
Positive
“I absolutely swear by Elf products too! So much bang for your buck!”
Positive
“PM: SA Cleanser, pure skin toner, niacinamide, elf holy hydration cream + holy hydration eye cream and finish with tactumpump”
Positive
“elf holy hydration cream + holy hydration eye cream”
Positive
“Might seem like a lot but elf is actually very affordable :)”
Positive
“I’m currently using elf holy hydration eye cream at night (with Tret)”
Positive
“this eye cream is exactly what I needed (a basic, moisturizing eye cream without a lot of crazy actives)”
Positive
“the elf holy hydration has worked well for me.”
Positive
“started using e.l.f. SKIN Holy Hydration! Eye Cream”
Positive
“When I'm consistent, the lines seen slightly less predominant.”
Positive
“Are there any products that would help?”
Positive
“I use the Elf holy hydration peptide eye cream and its working well so far.”
Positive
“Best eye cream for dark circles?”
Positive
“The dark circles under my (f35) eyes seem to be getting steadily worse with age.”
Positive
“e.l.f. Holy Hydration! Eye Cream, once daily, evening”
Positive
“bolded items are ones that have worked for me for a while that I'd like to keep using”
Positive
Other variants in this line
Same formula family — here’s what changes between them.
- EyeYou’re here
Holy Hydration! Eye Cream
7 mentions
FaceHoly Hydration! Face Cream
60 mentions
