nextbest

See what everyone's saying

Best Eye Creams & Serums to Wear Under Makeup

Ranked by 14 mentions across Reddit · Updated November 2026 · Edited by Kayleigh Migdol

Top picks· 6

Compare the top 5

Top pick

Budget pick

Reddit mentions33322
Pricefrom $11from $9from $28from $15from $9
Better for Anti-Aging————
Key ingredientsRetinal—Shea Butter—Bakuchiol, Sunflower Oil

Community take

Among eye creams Redditors report wearing under makeup, Kiehl’s avocado cream stands out for hydration and a smooth concealer base; the Beauty of Joseon serum is another lighter-layer option. Reported experiences are mostly positive.

What works

  • Kiehl’s avocado cream keeps the eye area hydrated and soft.
  • It layers smoothly under concealer, even with plenty of powder.
  • Beauty of Joseon’s thinner serum is also reported to wear well under makeup.

The full ranking

Browse by category

We use cookies to improve your experience. Learn more