nextbest

What Reddit actually recommends

← All brands

Best Olay Products

Olay on Reddit, in one place — 26 mentions across 3 products, from r/SkincareAddiction and more

26

Recommendations

See Reddit’s alternatives for every Olay product →

Reddit’s top pick from Olay

Community take

Olay is known for offering accessible, well-formulated skincare that targets anti-aging concerns like wrinkles and dullness. The community appreciates its effectiveness and reasonably affordable price point, especially the Regenerist line with retinol and peptides. However, some users find certain products too heavy or irritating, particularly if they have sensitive skin or prefer lighter textures.

42%

positive

Pros

  • Affordable price point making advanced skincare accessible
  • Effective anti-aging ingredients like retinol and peptides
  • Widely available and easy to find in stores

Watch out for

  • Some formulas can feel heavy or greasy for certain skin types
  • Retinol products may cause irritation for sensitive users

Real Reddit threads about Olay

2) Olay Super Serum

Positive

Night routine: Wash with CeraVe Foaming Cleanser and then use Olay Super Serum Night plus CeraVe Retinol

Positive

2. Olay Super Serum

Positive

Night routine: Wash with CeraVe Foaming Cleanser and then use Olay Super Serum Night plus CeraVe Retinol.

Positive

Your previous post inspired me to use the super serum but I think I hate it haha

Positive

Olay Regenerist

Positive

Before I was hell bent on trying olay super serum cream and one use is what caused my flare up.

Cautionary

My immediate guess was a dupe for the Olay Super Serum based on the packaging!!

Mentioned

moisturizer

night cream

serum

We use cookies to improve your experience. Learn more