Alternatives to Thayers — Reddit's Picks
From 186 Reddit mentions of 8 Thayers products
The short answer
Instead of Hydrating Milky Toner457 Reddit mentions
Instead of pH Balancing Daily Cleanser with Aloe Vera1,250 Reddit mentions
Instead of Hydrating Milky Toner
93 Reddit mentions of the original · original $12.60 · 354.9 ml
Layers well on damp skin for extra hydration
Best Overall Alternative
Gokujyun Premium Hyaluronic Acid Lotion
Hada Labo·Toner
Why: Reddit's top pick for Dehydration · Recommended for Sensitive Skin; the original is cautioned for it
Instead of Rose Petal Facial Toner
57 Reddit mentions of the original · original $10.95 · 355 ml
Alcohol-free, quick-drying formula · The catch: Can strip the barrier and worsen congestion
Best Overall Alternative
Glycolic Acid 7% Toning Solution
The Ordinary·Toner
Instead of pH Balancing Daily Cleanser with Aloe Vera
8 Reddit mentions of the original · original $13.63 · 236.6 ml
Aloe-loaded and anti-inflammatory; calms redness and soothes skin
Best Overall Alternative
Vanicream·Cleanser
Why: 27% less per ml ($0.04/ml vs $0.06/ml) · Reddit's complaint about the original: “Not potent enough for heavy makeup or oily skin”
All 10 alternatives to pH Balancing Daily Cleanser with Aloe Vera
Instead of Blemish Clearing 2% BHA Pads
7 Reddit mentions of the original
Pore-focused exfoliation with 2% salicylic acid · The catch: Burns when skin is already flaring
Best Overall Alternative
Paula's Choice·Acne Spot Treatment
Other Thayers dupes
nextbest surfaces what Reddit actually recommends. “Where to buy” links are affiliate links — we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.