Best Thayers Products
Thayers on Reddit, in one place — 179 mentions across 10 products, from r/SkincareAddiction and more
179
Recommendations
Reddit’s top pick from Thayers

Hyaluronic acid toner boosts damp-skin hydration; sticky finish, breakout risk.
Community take
Thayers’ lineup centers on toners, ranging from hydrating HA formulas to alcohol-free witch hazel, alongside gentle cleansers and targeted exfoliating products. Redditors praise the layering-friendly hydration and easy, gentle cleansing, though the experience varies by formula and skin type.
27%
positive
Pros
- The Hydrating Milky Toner layers well under makeup and is reported to boost moisturizer performance and improve the barrier.
- The Rose Petal Facial Toner is praised for drying quickly without a sticky finish, and for helping oily skin feel less slick.
- The Hydrating Milky Cleanser is notably non-stripping, while the pH Balancing Daily Cleanser is praised as simple and gentle.
Watch out for
- Breakouts can appear within a day; repeated-use bumps reported (Hydrating Milky Toner).
- Witch hazel can dehydrate and irritate dry or sensitive skin (Rose Petal Facial Toner).
- Can feel drying (pH Balancing Daily Cleanser with Aloe Vera).
Real Reddit threads about Thayers
In this thread
“Wash with CeraVe Foaming Cleanser and then use Thayers toner”
Positive
In this thread
“Toner: Thayers Alcohol-Free, Unscented Witch Hazel that is followed with Laneige Cream Skin Refiner/Toner”
Positive
“Toner: Thayers Alcohol-Free, Unscented Witch Hazel followed with Laneige Cream Skin Toner.”
Positive
“Thayers witch hazel”
Mentioned
“AM - micellar water, thayers rose water toner, laroche posay triple barrier repair moisturizer, supergoop radiant mineral SPF 40-50”
Positive
“Thayer’s milky toner applied while still damp”
Positive
acne spot treatment
cleanser
toner
toner pad
All 10 Thayers products
Edited by Kayleigh Migdol





