Best Thayers Products
Thayers on Reddit, in one place — 68 mentions across 6 products, from r/SkincareAddiction and more
68
Recommendations
Reddit’s top pick from Thayers
Witch hazel toner that can calm some skin; dries and irritates others.
Best Cleanser
Best Acne Spot Treatment
Best Toner Pad
Community take
Thayers is best known for its gentle, alcohol-free witch hazel toners infused with natural ingredients like aloe vera and rose petal, appealing to those looking for soothing, budget-friendly skincare staples. The community often praises Thayers for its affordability and suitability for sensitive skin, but opinions vary widely on its effectiveness, especially the BHA/AHA products which some find underwhelming or irritating. Overall, it's favored as a basic, gentle toner but less trusted as a potent exfoliating or acne-fighting solution.
28%
positive
Pros
- Gentle, alcohol-free formulations with natural ingredients like witch hazel and aloe vera
- Affordably priced, making it accessible for budget-conscious skincare users
- Well-suited for sensitive skin and daily gentle toning
Watch out for
- Mixed reviews on effectiveness of exfoliating and blemish-clearing products, with some users experiencing irritation
- Some community members find the BHA/AHA products less potent compared to other brands
- Fragrance in some products can be a turnoff or irritant for sensitive individuals
Real Reddit threads about Thayers
“Wash with CeraVe Foaming Cleanser and then use Thayers toner”
Positive
“Thayers witch hazel”
Mentioned
“AM - micellar water, thayers rose water toner, laroche posay triple barrier repair moisturizer, supergoop radiant mineral SPF 40-50”
Positive
“Thayers PH Balancing Daily Cleanser - My partner used this most of the time and they love this”
Positive
“I use some rose Thayers toner water to wet the adhesive to apply them at night before bed.”
Positive
“If you want a toner step, something like thayers witch hazel would be better.”
Mentioned
