nextbest

See what everyone's saying

Compare · Treatments

Cicaplast Gel B5 Skin Protectant vs Mederma Advanced Scar Gel: which is better?

This comparison comes down to whether you’re addressing tretinoin-related flaking and barrier recovery or redness in healing scars.

La Roche-Posay

Cicaplast Gel B5 Skin Protectant

Mederma

Advanced Scar Gel

Reddit’s pick

Cicaplast Gel B5 Skin Protectant

$17.29 at Amazon
  • Rated higher: Cicaplast Gel B5 Skin Protectant — 95 vs 73 nextscore 
  • More reviewed: Cicaplast Gel B5 Skin Protectant — 95 vs 22 verdicts

Cicaplast Gel B5 earns a clearly more positive reception; despite reports of irritation or breakouts, Redditors praise its help with tretinoin flaking and its clear, lightweight finish.

Choose Cicaplast Gel B5 Skin Protectant if

  • you want a lightweight gel for tretinoin flaking and barrier recovery
  • you prefer a clear, non-sticky finish under makeup

Choose Mederma Advanced Scar Gel if

  • you’re focused on bright-red scar marks after scabs have fallen off
  • you can stick with daily use despite a slow payoff

At a glance

Cicaplast Gel B5 Skin ProtectantMederma Advanced Scar Gel
Price per ml
$0.43/ml—
nextscore
95 · 95 verdicts73 · 22 verdicts
Key ingredients
PanthenolAllantoin
Skin type
Oily SkinCombination SkinDry SkinSensitive Skin—
Ingredients· 3 in common
19 ingredients
  1. Glycerin
  2. Water
  3. Dimethicone
  4. Panthenol
  5. Pentylene Glycol
  6. C30-45 Alkyl Dimethicone
  7. Polybutene
  8. Sodium Citrate
  9. PEG/PPG-18/18 Dimethicone
  10. Citric Acid
  11. Dimethiconol
  12. Polysorbate 20
  13. Madecassoside
  14. Caprylyl Glycol
  15. Sodium Hyaluronate
  16. Zinc Gluconate
  17. Copper Gluconate
  18. Manganese Gluconate
  19. Tocopherol
12 ingredients
  1. Allantoin
  2. Water
  3. PEG-4
  4. Alcohol
  5. Xanthan Gum
  6. Allium Cepa (Onion) Bulb Extract
  7. Panthenol
  8. Fragrance
  9. Lecithin
  10. Methylparaben
  11. Sorbic Acid
  12. Sodium Hyaluronate

Prices checked Nov 18

What Reddit says

Cicaplast Gel B5 Skin Protectant

What Reddit likes

  • 21% glycerin gel for tretinoin-flake rescue
  • Clear, lightweight, non-sticky finish under makeup
  • Gel texture preferred over heavier balm

Watch out for

  • Can burn severely on reactive or rosacea-prone skin
  • Breakouts, congestion, and fungal-acne flares reported
  • Pricey and not always enough as a standalone moisturizer

Mederma Advanced Scar Gel

What Reddit likes

  • Redness-fading scar gel for fully healed skin
  • Results improve with religious, months-long use

Watch out for

  • Not a quick fix; some users report no visible change after months
  • White marks and hypopigmentation have been reported
Compare full ingredient lists · 3 in common

Only in Cicaplast Gel B5 Skin Protectant · 16

  1. Glycerin
  2. Dimethicone
  3. Pentylene Glycol
  4. C30-45 Alkyl Dimethicone
  5. Polybutene
  6. Sodium Citrate
  7. PEG/PPG-18/18 Dimethicone
  8. Citric Acid
  9. Dimethiconol
  10. Polysorbate 20
  11. Madecassoside
  12. Caprylyl Glycol
  13. Zinc Gluconate
  14. Copper Gluconate
  15. Manganese Gluconate
  16. Tocopherol

Only in Mederma Advanced Scar Gel · 9

  1. Allantoin
  2. PEG-4
  3. Alcohol
  4. Xanthan Gum
  5. Allium Cepa (Onion) Bulb Extract
  6. Fragrance
  7. Lecithin
  8. Methylparaben
  9. Sorbic Acid

More treatments Reddit discusses

We use cookies to improve your experience. Learn more