Compare · Treatments
Cicaplast Gel B5 Skin Protectant vs Mederma Advanced Scar Gel: which is better?
This comparison comes down to whether you’re addressing tretinoin-related flaking and barrier recovery or redness in healing scars.

La Roche-Posay
Cicaplast Gel B5 Skin Protectant

Mederma
Advanced Scar Gel
Reddit’s pick
Cicaplast Gel B5 Skin Protectant
- Rated higher: Cicaplast Gel B5 Skin Protectant — 95 vs 73 nextscore nextscore is a 0–100 score built from verdicts: posts and comments that come down clearly for or against a product. Today those verdicts come from Reddit discussions. Thinly discussed products are pulled toward the catalog average, and below 5 verdicts there is no score at all. How nextscore works
- More reviewed: Cicaplast Gel B5 Skin Protectant — 95 vs 22 verdicts
Cicaplast Gel B5 earns a clearly more positive reception; despite reports of irritation or breakouts, Redditors praise its help with tretinoin flaking and its clear, lightweight finish.
Choose Cicaplast Gel B5 Skin Protectant if
- you want a lightweight gel for tretinoin flaking and barrier recovery
- you prefer a clear, non-sticky finish under makeup
Choose Mederma Advanced Scar Gel if
- you’re focused on bright-red scar marks after scabs have fallen off
- you can stick with daily use despite a slow payoff


At a glance
| Cicaplast Gel B5 Skin Protectant | Mederma Advanced Scar Gel |
|---|---|
| Price per ml | |
| $0.43/ml | — |
| nextscorenextscore is a 0–100 score built from verdicts: posts and comments that come down clearly for or against a product. Today those verdicts come from Reddit discussions. Thinly discussed products are pulled toward the catalog average, and below 5 verdicts there is no score at all. How nextscore works | |
| 95 · 95 verdicts | 73 · 22 verdicts |
| Key ingredients | |
| Panthenol | Allantoin |
| Skin type | |
| Oily SkinCombination SkinDry SkinSensitive Skin | — |
| Ingredients· 3 in common | |
19 ingredients
| 12 ingredients
|
Prices checked Nov 18
What Reddit says
Cicaplast Gel B5 Skin Protectant
What Reddit likes
- 21% glycerin gel for tretinoin-flake rescue
- Clear, lightweight, non-sticky finish under makeup
- Gel texture preferred over heavier balm
Watch out for
- Can burn severely on reactive or rosacea-prone skin
- Breakouts, congestion, and fungal-acne flares reported
- Pricey and not always enough as a standalone moisturizer
Mederma Advanced Scar Gel
What Reddit likes
- Redness-fading scar gel for fully healed skin
- Results improve with religious, months-long use
Watch out for
- Not a quick fix; some users report no visible change after months
- White marks and hypopigmentation have been reported
Compare full ingredient lists · 3 in common
In both · 3
Only in Cicaplast Gel B5 Skin Protectant · 16
- Glycerin
- Dimethicone
- Pentylene Glycol
- C30-45 Alkyl Dimethicone
- Polybutene
- Sodium Citrate
- PEG/PPG-18/18 Dimethicone
- Citric Acid
- Dimethiconol
- Polysorbate 20
- Madecassoside
- Caprylyl Glycol
- Zinc Gluconate
- Copper Gluconate
- Manganese Gluconate
- Tocopherol
Only in Mederma Advanced Scar Gel · 9
- Allantoin
- PEG-4
- Alcohol
- Xanthan Gum
- Allium Cepa (Onion) Bulb Extract
- Fragrance
- Lecithin
- Methylparaben
- Sorbic Acid







