
Madagascar Centella Toning Toner — Reddit Reviews
by Skin1004
Updated October 28, 2026
Centella toner calms irritation and adds subtle glow; sensitization happens.
What the community says
A watery centella toner with gluconolactone that Reddit users reach for when skin feels irritated, layering easily under serums and leaving a subtle glow. It is less convincing for dramatic brightening, and some long-term users report sensitization.
What this means for you
What people love
- Soothing, fragrance-free formula with centella
- Gluconolactone adds gentle exfoliation
- Light hydration, subtle glow, easy AM/PM layering
Product details
Concerns
Skin Type
Product Traits
Key Ingredients
What the science says
Acne
Some evidence
Niacinamide: 6 studies tested it directly. See all 17 studies
Hyperpigmentation
Some evidence
Niacinamide: 4 studies tested it directly. See all 17 studies
What the studies found
- All 4 studies that tested it directly found it helped fade dark spots or patches
- It reduced facial dark spots better than a moisturizer without niacinamide
- Women with chloasma saw darker patches improve more when nicotinamide was added to salicylic acid
- Studies also found facial skin looked lighter as dark spots faded
Anti-Aging
Some evidence
Niacinamide: 2 studies tested it directly. See all 8 studies
Skin Barrier
Not proven yet
Few or mixed studies. This claim isn't established.
Niacinamide: 1 study tested it directly. See all 17 studies
Redness/Irritation
Not proven yet
Few or mixed studies. This claim isn't established.
Centella/Cica: 1 study tested it directly. See all 2 studies
Research context, not treatment advice. Studies are about the ingredient, not necessarily this exact product.
Real Reddit threads — 28 mentions across 21 threads
Skin1004 Madagascar Centella Toning Toner on Reddit, in one place — 21 threads from r/koreanskincare, r/AsianBeauty and 3 more, summarized.
“Skin1004 tone brightening boosting toner 210 ml”
Cautionary
“It actually does nothing .Didnt notice any brightening effects”
Cautionary
“I dont really like watery toners as they drip down my arm and face and feel like they do nothing”
Cautionary
“I was able to get the water fit sunscreen, retinol 0.2% and toning toner.”
Mentioned
“I've seen these on social media which use a big scoop.”
Mentioned
“This one use a wooden spoon which holds max 2 or even 3 items.”
Mentioned
“skin1004 cica toner”
Cautionary
“Other cica products like One thing's cica extract and skin1004 triggered my fungal acne”
Cautionary
“so that's a bummer.”
Cautionary
“-Skin1004 Madagascar Centella Toning Toner”
Mentioned
“My new order from yesstyle, it's one order but it was divided into 2 shipments:”
Mentioned
“-Skin1004 Double Cleansing Duo Set”
Mentioned
“SKIN1004 Madagascar Centella Toning Toner”
Mentioned
“Skin1004 toner does contain phas (gentle exfoliants) so make sure ure mindful of that...”
Mentioned
“I’m currently considering these products: * SKIN1004 Madagascar Centella Toning Toner *”
Mentioned
“Another favorite of mine is the Skin1004 Centella toner.”
Positive
“It made my skin more clear (had less problems with whiteheads) and smooth.”
Positive
“Personally prefer this one over I'm From, but both are good toners imho.”
Positive





