Unscented Alcohol-Free Witch Hazel Facial Toner — Reddit Reviews
by Thayers
Updated September 26, 2026
Witch hazel toner for post-cleansing residue; can dry out sensitive skin.
What the community says
A glycerin-and-aloe toner with witch hazel for people who want a swipe of extra residue removal after cleansing. It fits better for combo or oily skin than dry, sensitive, or redness-prone skin, which people said it can aggravate.
What this means for you
What people love
- Alcohol-free and fragrance-free
- Glycerin plus aloe keeps it from feeling totally harsh
- Can help lift leftover gunk after cleansing
Watch out for
- Can dry out sensitive skin over time
- Not helping dry patches
- Some users said it made redness worse
Product details
Product Traits
Key Ingredients
Skin type data limited
Where to buy
Real Reddit threads — 6 mentions across 4 threads
Thayers Unscented Alcohol-Free Witch Hazel Facial Toner on Reddit, in one place — 4 threads from r/eczema and r/SkincareAddiction, summarized.
“Thayers Cucumber Alcohol-Free Toner”
Positive
“I like Thayers for my body:”
Positive
“Try a simple hydrating toner to begin with”
Positive
“Thayer unscented toner”
Positive
“Cleanser, toner, treatment, serum, moisturiser, sunscreen.”
Positive
“AM - toner”
Positive
“Things I have tried in that past that I know don’t work for me: salicylic acid, benzoyl peroxide, Differin adapalene gel, several good molecules brand products, several byoma brand products, thayers unscented toner”
Cautionary
“I tried all of those things mostly at separate times but after a few months saw no results or they made my redness worse.”
Cautionary
“thayers unscented toner”
Cautionary
“2. thayer's unscented witch hazel toner (am & pm)”
Cautionary
“The Thayers witch hazel can be dropped because it’s not helping with your dry patches.”
Cautionary
“i'd drop the witch hazel too since alcohol-based toners tend to dry out sensitive skin over time”
Cautionary
