nextbest

See what everyone's saying

Compare · Cleansers

Tolerance Extremely Gentle Cleanser vs Vanicream Gentle Facial Cleanser: which is better?

Both cleansers skew gentle, but the real difference is whether you want a lotion-like wash or a more basic gel cleanser.

The quick answer

Depends what you need

  • Rated higher: Tolerance Extremely Gentle Cleanser — 91 vs 85 nextscore
  • More reviewed: Vanicream Gentle Facial Cleanser — 588 vs 61 verdicts

Avene suits flare-prone, rosacea-leaning skin that wants a creamier cleanse; Vanicream suits people who want a simpler, no-actives gel and can tolerate a stronger wash.

Choose Tolerance Extremely Gentle Cleanser if

  • you have hypersensitive or rosacea-prone skin
  • you want a creamy, low-stripping cleanser

Choose Vanicream Gentle Facial Cleanser if

  • you want a fragrance-free, soap-free gel
  • you prefer a simple cleanser for reactive-skin routines

At a glance

Tolerance Extremely Gentle CleanserVanicream Gentle Facial Cleanser
—$0.04/ml
91 · 61 verdicts85 · 588 verdicts

What Reddit says

Tolerance Extremely Gentle Cleanser

What Reddit likes

  • Rosacea fave for flare-prone skin
  • Creamy, low-surfactant texture
  • Fragrance-free and niacinamide-free

Watch out for

  • Can feel drying or tight on already dry skin
  • Some people get congestion or pore-clogging
  • Not enough for makeup or SPF unless used carefully
See the Reddit threads on Tolerance Extremely Gentle Cleanser

Vanicream Gentle Facial Cleanser

What Reddit likes

  • Fragrance-free, soap-free, no actives
  • Boring-better cleansing for tret routines
  • HG status for very reactive skin

Watch out for

  • Can leave dry skin tight and stripped
  • Rosacea users report burning and flareups
  • Not enough for heavy sunscreen or makeup
See the Reddit threads on Vanicream Gentle Facial Cleanser
Compare full ingredient lists · 3 in common

In both · 3

  1. Caprylyl Glycol
  2. Coco-Glucoside
  3. Sodium Hydroxide

Only in Tolerance Extremely Gentle Cleanser · 12

  1. Avene Thermal Spring Water (Avene Aqua)
  2. Cetearyl Alcohol
  3. Aquaphilus Dolomiae Extract Filtrate
  4. Arginine
  5. Cetrimonium Bromide
  6. Disodium Phosphate
  7. Hydroxycapric Acid
  8. Magnesium Oxide
  9. Potassium Phosphate
  10. Sodium Benzoate
  11. Sodium Cetearyl Sulfate
  12. Tromethamine

Only in Vanicream Gentle Facial Cleanser · 9

  1. Water
  2. Glycerin
  3. Sodium Cocoyl Glycinate
  4. Acrylates Copolymer
  5. Mica
  6. Sodium Chloride
  7. 1,2-Hexanediol
  8. Titanium Dioxide
  9. Disodium EDTA

We use cookies to improve your experience. Learn more